Wednesday, October 28, 2009

15-Year-Old to be Charged as a Juvenile

We discussed the story at the time when Kaleb Eulls tackled the gun-wielding girl on a school bus and became a national hero. Now the story is back in the news because it's been decided that the girl, now 15, should be charged as a juvenile. From wlbt.com:

YAZOO COUNTY, MS (WLBT) - The case of a 15 year old taking a gun on a school bus in Yazoo County, Mississippi will be handled in youth court.

District Attorney James Powell said he carefully studied the video tape of the incident, from a school bus camera and he does not see that the child actually intended to harm anybody.

"I think it is best handled in Youth Court," said Powell.

Powell said the sheriff's department told him there was not actually a bullet in the chamber of the .380 semi automatic pistol, although the girl had put a clip of bullets into the weapon.

Kaleb Eulls a star football player made national news by tackling the 15 year old and disarming her.


Do you wonder, like I do, where the gun came from? Do you wonder if her daddy taught her to play with guns? That's what I wonder. Maybe she'd had all the proper upbringing you could hope for and turned out bad anyway. What do you think?

What's your opinion? Should the judge and the courts be concerned with the home life of juvenile defendants? Would their upbringing be considered a mitigating circumstance?

Does the fact that the gun was unloaded lessen her culpability? Is there anyone who thinks she should be tried as an adult?

Please leave a comment.

4 comments:

  1. Would their upbringing be considered a mitigating circumstance?

    Does the fact that the gun was unloaded lessen her culpability? Is there anyone who thinks she should be tried as an adult?


    No, No, and yes. A 15 year old knows better. She knew (or should have known) damn well that it was not OK to bring a gun to school.

    The fact that it was unloaded doesn't make it any less of a crime.

    ReplyDelete
  2. "Do you wonder if her daddy taught her to play with guns? That's what I wonder. Maybe she'd had all the proper upbringing you could hope for and turned out bad anyway."

    A proper upbringing concerning firearms does not involve playing with guns.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I'm hoping Co-Chair Tom "Mumbles" Menino gets the boot this year in his election. He's in for a serious fight. If not he might be facing pay-to-play charges for bartering liquor licenses in the city.

    Why is it so many of the Mayors against guns are criminals? Why is it so many anti-gun bigots are criminals?

    ReplyDelete
  4. kaveman said, "A proper upbringing concerning firearms does not involve playing with guns."

    The operative word is "proper." The problem is not all of you guys know what that is. I'd guess the ones who don't are about 10%. What do you think?

    ReplyDelete